Skip to Content
Serving Los Angeles County and the Greater Southern California Area
Se Habla Español
(310) 361-3068

Public Defenders vs. Private Criminal Defense Attorneys

person consulting a lawyer

When faced with criminal charges, one of your most critical decisions is choosing your legal representation. You have two primary options: a public defender or a private criminal defense attorney. Both have their merits and drawbacks and understanding the differences can help you make an informed decision.

Public Defenders

Public defenders are court-appointed attorneys provided to defendants who cannot afford to hire a private attorney. They are funded by the government and are typically assigned to individuals who meet specific financial criteria.

Here are some key points about public defenders:

  1. Cost: The most significant advantage of public defenders is that their services are free for eligible defendants. If you qualify based on your financial situation, you won't have to worry about legal fees, which can be substantial in a criminal case.

  2. Experience: Public defenders are often highly experienced in criminal law. They handle numerous cases and are familiar with local court systems, judges, and prosecutors. This experience can be beneficial in navigating the complexities of the criminal justice system.

  3. Workload: One of the main drawbacks of public defenders is their heavy caseloads. Due to limited funding and resources, public defenders often juggle many cases simultaneously, impacting how much time and attention they can dedicate to your case. This high workload can lead to less personalized representation.

  4. Resources: Public defenders might have limited access to resources such as private investigators, expert witnesses, and other tools that can be crucial in building a strong defense. This lack of resources can sometimes hinder their ability to provide the most robust defense possible.

Private Criminal Defense Attorneys

Private criminal defense attorneys are hired directly by defendants or their families. They charge fees for their services, which can vary widely based on the attorney's experience, reputation, and the case's complexity.

Here are some key points about private criminal defense attorneys:

  1. Personalized Attention: Private attorneys typically manage fewer cases than public defenders, allowing them to dedicate more time and attention to each client. This can result in a more personalized and thorough defense strategy tailored to the specifics of your case.

  2. Resources: Private attorneys usually have better access to resources. They can hire private investigators, expert witnesses, and other professionals who can provide valuable insights and evidence to support your defense.

  3. Choice: When hiring a private attorney, you can choose who will represent you. This choice allows you to select an attorney with specific experience or expertise that aligns with your case, giving you greater control over your defense.

  4. Cost: The primary disadvantage of private attorneys is the cost. Legal fees can be significant, especially in complex or high-stakes cases. However, many private attorneys offer payment plans or sliding scale fees to make their services more accessible.

Making the Decision

Deciding between a public defender and a private attorney depends on several factors, including your financial situation, the complexity of your case, and your personal preferences. 

  • Financial Situation: If you cannot afford a private attorney, a public defender is a viable and often necessary option. They can provide competent representation without the financial burden.

  • Case Complexity: A private attorney may be better equipped to provide the necessary resources and attention for more complex or high-stakes cases. Their ability to focus on fewer cases and utilize additional resources can be crucial in such situations.

  • Personal Preference: Some defendants prefer the ability to choose their attorney and have more direct communication and personalized attention. If this is important to you, a private attorney may be the better choice.

Choosing the Right Defense: Why a Private Attorney Might Be Your Best Bet

While public defenders and criminal defense attorneys offer valuable services, a private attorney often provides a distinct advantage, particularly for complex or high-stakes cases. With personalized attention, access to extensive resources, and the ability to choose your representative, a private attorney can significantly enhance your defense strategy.

Reach out to Ernenwein & Mathes, LLP today at (310) 361-3068 to learn more.

Share To: